Costs, licensing, consumer protection Privacy, self-custody, censorship resistance

Coldcard

Coinkite Inc.

3.6/5 4.3/5 · Data verified on

Coldcard, made by Canada's Coinkite, is the reference hardware wallet for Bitcoin-only holders: its firmware is Bitcoin-only and built for fully air-gapped use, signing transactions offline via microSD (or QR on the Q model) without ever plugging the device into a computer. It uses two secure elements from different vendors (Microchip ATECC608 and Maxim DS28C36B) to protect the seed. The current lineup includes the Coldcard Mk5 (≈€159, successor to the Mk4) and the Coldcard Q (≈€230) with a QWERTY keyboard, QR scanner and AAA batteries for fully offline operation. ⚠️ On 31 July 2026 an entropy flaw in the firmware (present since 4.0.0, March 2021) made device-generated seeds guessable: ~594 BTC drained from ~500 wallets. Coinkite has released fixed firmware, but seeds generated on vulnerable firmware must be replaced (see the Reputation block).

RISK: Critical incident ongoing (advisory 30 Jul 2026): firmware entropy flaw since 2021, ≥1,367 BTC (~$89M) stolen as of 2 Aug 2026 with the attack still active. Seeds generated on-device with vulnerable firmware must be REPLACED (new seed + fund migration): updating firmware is not enough. Coinkite also admitted retaining customer emails since 2019, contradicting its promise to delete them after 90 days.
46
Transparency: Low
46/100 · see methodology
46
Data exposure: Low
46/100 · lower is better for sovereignty · methodology

Data & conditions

Fund custody Self-custody (funds in your control)
Type Hardware (cold storage)
Source code Partly open-source
Recovery Seed phrase 12/24 parole (BIP-39); backup cifrato su microSD
Bitcoin-only Yes
Supported chains Bitcoin
Price €159
Secure element Yes
Air-gapped Yes
Connectivity USB-C, NFC, microSD, QR
Companion app Sparrow / Nunchuk / Electrum / Bitcoin Core (PSBT)
Built-in swap No
Built-in staking No
Segment B2C
MiCA / License status Nessuna (hardware wallet self-custody)

Plans & pricing

Strengths

  • Bitcoin-only with focused firmware; fully air-gapped use via microSD/QR; two secure elements from different vendors; Q model with QWERTY, QR scanner and AAA batteries.
  • Self-custody: funds stay in your wallet — the platform cannot touch them.
  • No KYC: usable without identity verification.
  • Self-hostable: you can run your own instance or node.

Weaknesses

  • Bitcoin-only (no multi-asset support); steep learning curve aimed at advanced users; Q priced above average; open-source firmware under a non-standard licence.
  • July 2026: an entropy flaw in the firmware (since 4.0.0, March 2021) made device-generated seeds guessable — ~594 BTC (~$38M) stolen from ~500 wallets. Seeds generated on vulnerable firmware remain at risk even after updating.
  • No notable sovereignty drawback documented.

Verdict

B A ★ 3.6/5 ★ 4.3/5

Score 3.6/5, solid profile. In its favour: bitcoin-only with focused firmware; fully air-gapped use via microSD/QR; two secure elements from different vendors; Q model with QWERTY, QR scanner and AAA batteries. The trade-off to weigh: bitcoin-only (no multi-asset support); steep learning curve aimed at advanced users; Q priced above average; open-source firmware under a non-standard licence.

On the Sovereignty lens the score is 4.3/5 (very strong): the strength is fund control (5.0/5), while trustless / auditability (2.5/5) is the weak link.

Privacy & anonymity 30% 4.8
Fund control 20% 5.0
Censorship resistance 20% 4.8
Trustless / auditability 20% 2.5

Promp's editorial rating based on real fees and net annual cost. Promp reviews third-party products independently.

"Sovereignty" rating: score computed on privacy/anonymity (30%), fund control (20%), censorship resistance (20%), trustless/auditability (20%) and costs (10%). Same data, different weights.

Reputation

What happened to people who used Coldcard, and what users say. External signals: they do not feed the promp.it rating.

Incidents & regulatory actions

Notable incidents

Documented events with consequences still open. Each entry carries a source and a date.

  1. Hack / funds theft Critical $89M ● open

    ≥1,367 BTC (~$89M) stolen from ~4,585 addresses due to an entropy flaw in seed generation — attack ongoing

    Since firmware 4.0.0 (March 2021) seed generation skipped the hardware randomness generator and fell back to a predictable software PRNG: effective entropy ~40 bits on Mk2/Mk3 (fw 4.0.1–4.1.9), ~72 bits on Mk4/Mk5/Q. Coinkite advisory on 30 Jul 2026; first wave on 30 Jul drained ~1,082 BTC (~$70M) from ~1,196 addresses in ~41 minutes (early estimates: 594 BTC), followed by further waves: as of 2 Aug 2026, ≥1,367 BTC (~$89M) from ~4,585 addresses, attack still ongoing. Fixed firmware within ~24h (Mk3 4.2.0+, Mk4/Mk5 5.6.0+, Q 1.5.0Q+, Edge 6.6.0X/QX+), but updating does NOT repair existing seeds: anyone who generated their seed on-device must create a new one and migrate funds. Seeds from ≥50 dice rolls or imported elsewhere are unaffected; a BIP-39 passphrase lowers the risk. TAPSIGNER, OPENDIME and SATSCARD not affected. Stolen funds not recovered.

    ↗ source

verified on

FAQ

How much does a Coldcard cost?

The Coldcard Mk5 costs about €159 ($169.94 on Coinkite's official store), while the Coldcard Q, with QWERTY keyboard and QR scanner, costs about €230 ($249.21). Prices are in US dollars and orders ship from Canada: customs duties, VAT and clearance fees are the buyer's responsibility.

Does Coldcard support coins other than Bitcoin?

No: Coldcard is Bitcoin-only by design. The firmware is dedicated to Bitcoin alone to reduce the attack surface and stay focused on security.

Is Coldcard air-gapped?

Yes: it can run fully offline by signing transactions via microSD, or via QR on the Q model, without ever connecting to a computer. It also uses two secure elements from different vendors.

What happened in the July 2026 theft and what should I do?

On 31 July 2026 about 594 BTC (~$38 million) were drained from ~500 Coldcard wallets in 25 minutes. Cause: a build error introduced with firmware 4.0.0 (March 2021) skipped the hardware randomness generator, making seeds guessable — Mk3 (fw 4.0.1–4.1.9) most exposed, but Mk4, Mk5 and Q are affected too. If your seed was generated on the device with vulnerable firmware: update the firmware (Mk3 ≥4.2.0, Mk4/Mk5 ≥5.6.0, Q ≥1.5.0Q), generate a NEW seed and move funds there — updating alone does not repair existing seeds. Seeds created with ≥50 dice rolls are not affected.

Sources

Show 3 more sources

Update history

  1. reputazione.incidenti Updated exploit figures: as of Aug 2, ≥1,367 BTC (~$89M) from ~4,585 addresses, attack ongoing (first estimate: 594 BTC). Noted the controversy over customer emails retained since 2019 despite a 90-day deletion promise (not a data breach).
  2. rating_editoriale 4.4 3.6 Rating cut after the seed exploit: the flaw sat at the core of the product's security promise.

🔔 Notify me of changes

← Back to Hardware Wallets