Costs, licensing, consumer protection Privacy, self-custody, censorship resistance

Tinaba — Deposito Vincolato (Banca Profilo)

Banca Profilo S.p.A. (app Tinaba S.p.A.)

3.3/5 0.4/5 · Data verified on

Tinaba's fixed-term deposit is issued by Banca Profilo and activated from the app, provided you already hold a Tinaba Wallet. Rates split across two levels: the standard ones, for customers opening the wallet through the digital channel, reach 2.50% gross at 12 months; the "Tinaba Premium" ones rise to 3.00%, but require signing a specific agreement and keeping the Premium membership active until the term matures. Unlike almost every competitor, early release is available here — except it zeroes the interest: you get the capital back and nothing else. Stamp duty stays with the customer, which is why the Premium 3.00% is worth 2.02% net. Entry is €1,000, and at maturity capital and interest return to the Wallet on their own.

46
Transparency: Low
46/100 · see methodology
46
Data exposure: Low
46/100 · lower is better for sovereignty · methodology

Data & conditions

Max gross rate 2.5%
Max net rate 1.65% — tax and stamp duty take 34%
Account type Fixed term
Available terms 3m · 6m · 12m · 18m · 24m — up to 2.5% gross
Early withdrawal Yes
What early withdrawal costs Early release is allowed but wipes out the return: the information sheet provides that on early closure the customer «will not receive the interest» and gets back only the capital, net of stamp duty and withholding. On partial release, interest is recalculated from the start on the remaining sums only.
Accrued interest forfeited Yes
Interest compounding At maturity
Interest paid upfront No
Stamp duty Paid by you — 0.2% of the balance per year
Deposit amount €1,000 – €10,000,000
Deposit guarantee EU guarantee €100,000
Automatic rollover No
Requires a linked current account Yes
Supported countries EEA · 1+ countries
Regulator Banca d'Italia
Segment B2C
Funding / solidityDeposit issued by Banca Profilo, a listed private bank; Tinaba is the app that distributes it
MiCA / License status Licenza bancaria (Banca d'Italia) Italian banking licence (Bank of Italy)

Strengths

  • Early release is contractually available, partial or total: rare in this category, where an outright ban is the norm.
  • At maturity capital and interest are credited automatically to the Wallet, with no written requests or steps to remember.
  • Entry from €1,000 and a very high ceiling (€10m on the standard profile), with opening, closing and early release all free.
  • No notable sovereignty advantage documented.

Weaknesses

  • Early release zeroes the return: you get the capital back but not a euro of interest. The flexibility exists on paper, but costs everything the deposit would have earned.
  • The 3.00% is reserved for Tinaba Premium customers and requires signing an agreement and keeping the membership until the term matures: if it lapses, so does the rate. We headline 2.50%, the rate obtainable without membership.
  • Saw-tooth curve here too: 18 and 24 months pay 2.00% against 2.50% at 12 months on the standard profile.
  • The rates apply to sums locked by 29 July 2026: these are window conditions, not standing ones.
  • Custodial: the platform holds your funds and can freeze or lose them.
  • Full KYC required: verified identity, zero pseudonymity.
  • Subject to regulation (Italian banking licence (Bank of Italy)): reporting to authorities and freezes on order.

Verdict

B D ★ 3.3/5 ★ 0.4/5

Score 3.3/5, solid profile. In its favour: early release is contractually available, partial or total: rare in this category, where an outright ban is the norm. The trade-off to weigh: early release zeroes the return: you get the capital back but not a euro of interest. The flexibility exists on paper, but costs everything the deposit would have earned.

On the Sovereignty lens the score is 0.4/5 (weak): the strength is censorship resistance (1.5/5), while fund control (0.0/5) is the weak link.

Privacy & anonymity 30% 0.0
Fund control 20% 0.0
Censorship resistance 20% 1.5

Promp's editorial rating based on real fees and net annual cost. Promp reviews third-party products independently.

"Sovereignty" rating: score computed on privacy/anonymity (30%), fund control (20%), censorship resistance (20%), trustless/auditability (20%) and costs (10%). Same data, different weights.

FAQ

Can I really withdraw whenever I want?

Yes, but at zero return. The July 2026 information sheet provides that on early closure the customer does not receive the interest and is returned only the sum held on the deposit, net of stamp duty and withholding tax. On partial release, interest is recalculated from the start of the period on the remaining locked sums only. The exit exists; the gain does not.

Why do you show 2.50% and not the 3.00% Tinaba advertises?

Because 3.00% is the Tinaba Premium column, which the information sheet conditions on signing a specific agreement, activating the Premium membership and keeping it until the term matures. The 2.50% instead applies to standard customers who open the wallet through the digital channel, with nothing extra to sign. We headline the figure obtainable without additional conditions.

What does the Premium 3.00% pay net?

2.02%. The information sheet explicitly lists stamp duty as «borne by the customer», so from 3.00% gross you subtract the 26% withholding and then the 0.2% duty on the balance: 3.00 × 0.74 − 0.2 = 2.02%. The standard 2.50%, on the same maths, is worth 1.65% net.

Do I need the Tinaba app?

Yes. The information sheet states that to use the fixed-term deposit the customer must have signed the Wallet contract with the Bank. The deposit does not exist as a standalone product: capital and interest move through the Tinaba Wallet.

Who actually holds my money?

Banca Profilo S.p.A., a listed Italian bank: Tinaba is the app that distributes the product. Protection is the Italian deposit guarantee scheme, up to €100,000 per depositor; above that threshold you fall within the scope of bail-in.

Sources

Update history

✓ Terms unchanged since Jul 27, 2026

🔔 Notify me of changes

← Back to Italian Savings & Deposit Accounts